Cast big bucktail spinners and topwater baits over shallow grassbeds in June. As summer comes on, switch to oversize crankbaits such as the 10-inch Jake and 9-inch Grandma in shad patterns in the middle of the lake, where muskies often feed on big gizzard shad. If you can find schools of these baitfish on your depthfinder before you start casting, you'll improve your odds dramatically. Look for open water and bait schools. The muskies are usually down about 25 to 45 feet. Where to Fish: The main lake basin is the place to go.
It may be only 774 acres, but Webster has been stocked with muskies since 1980 and holds good numbers of them up to 42 pounds. The main portion of Webster Lake consists of about 640 surface acres of water, and 9 miles of shoreline. Webster Lake and the Backwater area combined represent more than 1,000 surface acres. The lake has a maximum depth of 65 feet, and an average depth of 7 feet. Webster Lake is the headwaters of the Tippecanoe River. Webster Lake in northcentral Indiana has hotels, boating, fishing, campgrounds,and all other recreations you could possibly want to find.